Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

8 August 2008

Hamdan sentenced by military commission

Hamdan sentenced by military commission
Salim Hamdan was sentenced on 7 August to five and a half years in prison at the first US military commission trial in Guantánamo Bay. The prosecution had asked for a sentence of not less than 30 years.

The day before, a panel of six US military officers had convicted Hamdan of “providing material support for terrorism” and acquitted him of “conspiracy”.

His sentence includes credit for the 61 months and eight days he has spent in detention at Guantánamo since he was first made eligible for trial in 2003. This was under the previous military commission system authorized by presidential order but subsequently ruled unlawful by the US Supreme Court in 2006.

In an ordinary justice system, this would mean that he would be released in less than five months time. On 5 August, however, the Pentagon suggested that Salim Hamdan would remain in indefinite detention as an “enemy combatant” regardless of the verdict.

Matt Pollard, legal adviser for Amnesty International, said Hamdan's conviction was based on a proceeding that "fundamentally failed to meet international fair trial standards."

"To impose any penalty based on it therefore could only aggravate the injustice of the trial and the other human rights violations during his many years of unlawful detention," he said.

The framework of laws and rules within which the military commissions operate is fundamentally at odds with international law, and has been criticized around the world. Nevertheless, it appears that the US authorities plan to press on, subjecting numerous more Guantánamo detainees to these unlawful procedures.

Amnesty International considers that the military commission system is fundamentally flawed and should be abandoned. The organization continues to campaign for any trials of Guantánamo detainees to be held in ordinary civilian courts in the USA, without resort to the death penalty, and for the Guantánamo detention facility to be shut down.

Read More

Observing Guantánamo's military commission hearings (Part I) (Feature, 5 August 2008)
Observing Guantánamo's military commission hearings (Part 2) (Feature, 6 August 2008)
Hamdan convicted at Guantánamo (News story, 6 August 2008)
USA: Trial and error - a reflection on the first week of the first military commission trial at Guantánamo (Report, 30 July 2008)
USA: Back to the bigger picture (Report, 8 August 2008)

Issue

Detention 
Trials And Legal Systems 

Country

USA 

Region

Americas 

Campaigns

Security with Human Rights 

@amnestyonline on twitter

News

18 September 2014

Nigeria’s police and military routinely torture women, men, and children – some as young as 12 – using a wide range of methods including beatings, shootings and rape... Read more »

19 September 2014

The Guatemalan government is fuelling the fires of conflict by failing to consult local communities before awarding mining licences to companies.

Read more »
23 September 2014

The life sentence handed down by a Chinese court to prominent Uighur academic Ilham Tohti on charges of “separatism” is an affront to justice.

Read more »
22 September 2014

Turkey began to close some of its border crossings with Syria after 130,000 Kurdish refugees poured into the country in recent days fleeing the advance of the armed group... Read more »

22 September 2014

Turkey began to close some of its border crossings with Syria after 130,000 Kurdish refugees poured into the country in recent days fleeing the advance of the armed group... Read more »