Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

29 October 2012

Blog: The Shell Game

Blog: The Shell Game
Leaks in oil pipes in Nigeria were allowed to flow for 10 weeks before Shell came to the site to stop them.

Leaks in oil pipes in Nigeria were allowed to flow for 10 weeks before Shell came to the site to stop them.

© Amnesty International


See video
Shell has said that the damage at Bodo is due to later oil spills caused by sabotage and acts of theft. Amnesty International has asked for the evidence to support these allegations but has received no answers.
Source: 
Audrey Gaughran, Director of Amnesty International’s Africa Programme

Audrey Gaughran, Director of Amnesty International’s Africa Programme

For decades the oil industry in Nigeria’s Niger Delta has caused widespread pollution of land and water, damaging people’s ability to fish and farm, and putting their health at risk.

I have worked on Amnesty International’s campaign to urge Shell and the government of Nigeria to address the human rights impact of oil pollution in the Niger Delta for several years.

Earlier this month I had the chance to debate with Shell on the issue.

The exchange focused on two major oil spills in 2008 at a town called Bodo. During the debate, Shell put forward some entirely new claims about the Bodo disaster. As with many of its previous statements on this case, these new claims do not stand up to scrutiny.

The Bodo spills were both caused by leaks in Shell’s pipes and both were allowed to flow for 10 weeks before Shell came to the site to stop them.

During the NRK Telethon debate earlier this month, Shell stated that the 2008 oil spills at Bodo lasted only three and seven days respectively.

This ‘fact’ is contradicted by all the existing evidence. 

The oil spill investigation reports for Bodo, compiled by Shell, show that the first spill began on 5 October 2008  - a date itself disputed by the community and the government regulator who both give 28 August 2008 as the start date.

The same report shows that the investigation into the spill took place more then one month later on 7 November 2008, at which point the spill was still flowing, as seen on video of the investigation.

The second spill was recorded as starting on 7 December 2008 and the investigation, which included stopping the oil flow, was carried out more then two months later between 19 and 21 February 2009.

How can this be three or seven days? 

In an effort to support this completely new and bizarre statement, Shell’s representative claimed his company closed off the oil flows when the spills were reported. 

In the four years since these spills occurred, this is the first time Shell has made this claim. 

And if the oil flow was turned off, how is it possible that there is video footage of the oil still flowing on 7 November 2008, when Shell came to the site to clamp the pipe?
 
Shell’s previous statements about Bodo also don't square with the evidence. For example, the company has denied that a large amount of oil was spilt at Bodo.

But the independent assessment we obtained of the rate at which oil gushed from the pipe showed Shell significantly underestimated the quantity of the first spill.
 
Shell also claims it has cleaned up the spills. However, this is disputed by video footage which clearly shows that Bodo remains polluted, as well as the testimony of the community.

Shell has said that the damage at Bodo is due to later oil spills caused by sabotage and acts of theft. Amnesty International has asked for the evidence to support these allegations but has received no answers.

The people of Bodo are living in an intolerable situation. Their human rights to food, health and livelihood have been undermined by corporate pollution, but they have not been able to get justice in Nigeria. They have now taken their case to the UK courts.

Amnesty International is committed to working with communities like Bodo, to help level the playing field between extraordinary corporate power and the victims of corporate abuse. The Norwegian telethon is helping to support this vital work.

Issue

Business And Human Rights 
Demand Dignity 
Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 
Impunity 
Medical And Health 

Country

Nigeria 

Region

Africa 

Campaigns

Demand Dignity 

@amnestyonline on twitter

News

18 September 2014

Nigeria’s police and military routinely torture women, men, and children – some as young as 12 – using a wide range of methods including beatings, shootings and rape... Read more »

25 September 2014

El Salvador has one of the most restrictive abortion laws in the world. Abortion is totally banned in all circumstances and harsh prison sentences befall those accused of... Read more »

01 October 2014

The Chinese authorities must release all those detained for peacefully showing support for pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong.

Read more »
01 October 2014

Ukrainian and rebel forces must immediately end indiscriminate attacks in residential areas, Amnesty International said after at least nine civilians were killed in... Read more »

29 September 2014

Iranian authorities have today confirmed that a woman convicted of killing a man whom she said tried to sexually abuse her will be hanged tomorrow morning at a prison... Read more »