Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

22 April 2013

Brazil prison massacre verdict a 'vital' step towards justice

Brazil prison massacre verdict a 'vital' step towards justice
More than 100 inmates were killed in the Carandiru prison massacre

More than 100 inmates were killed in the Carandiru prison massacre

© Amnesty International


"This vital, if long overdue, ruling will hopefully kickstart a process that brings all those responsible for the killings to justice, including those in command."
Source: 
Amnesty International's Atila Roque

The conviction of 23 Brazilian police officers for killing inmates in a prison massacre two decades ago is a "vital" step towards justice, Amnesty International has said.

The officers were sentenced yesterday to 156 years each in jail for their role in the deaths of 13 inmates during bloody riots at São Paulo's Carandiru prison in 1992, in which more than 100 inmates died.

"The victims, their families and survivors of this brutal, shocking crime have waited 20 years for justice," said Atila Roque, Director of Amnesty International in Brazil.

"This vital, if long overdue, ruling will hopefully kickstart a process that brings all those responsible for the killings to justice, including those in command."

The Carandiru case has become emblematic of the flaws in São Paulo’s criminal justice system and its inability to deal with human rights violations.

The authorities have failed to investigate the role of senior state government officials, while the conviction of the military operation’s commanding officer Colonel Ubiratan Guimarães was controversially overturned in 2006.

Military police shock troops were sent into Carandiru when a fight among prisoners, who had seized control of the jail’s Block 9, escalated into a riot on 2 October 1992.

Within days of the massacre, an Amnesty International team visited the prison to gather evidence, which was used to compile a unique record of what had occurred in each of the cells in Block 9.

They were also able to evaluate forensic evidence and document the inadequate handling of ballistics evidence, which amounted to an attempted cover-up by officials.

The report Brazil: "Death has arrived" found that São Paulo’s Governor and Secretary of Public Security abdicated their responsibilities by handing complete control of the prison to the military police and were therefore also responsible for what happened.

Dozens more police officers are expected to be brought to trial in connection with the Carandiru case in the coming months, but no senior government figures are set to be held accountable.

Meanwhile, lawyers for the convicted police officers have said they will appeal against this weekend's verdicts.

"With this verdict, the São Paulo judicial system has at last recognised the culpability of individual police officers for the killings that occurred in Carandiru," said Atila Roque.

"However, these officers did not act alone. It is now essential that those responsible for the actions of the police that day also face justice.”

Read More

Carandiru and the scandal of Brazil’s medieval prison system (News, 15 April 2013)

Country

Brazil 

Region

Americas 

Issue

Extrajudicial Executions And Other Unlawful Killings 
Impunity 
Prison Conditions 
Trials And Legal Systems 

Follow #Brazil @amnestyonline on twitter

News

24 October 2014

Equatorial Guinea’s government should reveal the names and the reasons for the arrest of all prisoners set to benefit from the country’s newly announced amnesty on... Read more »

24 October 2014

The dismissive reaction of the Dominican Republic to the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ ruling on human rights abuses suffered by Dominicans of Haitian descent and... Read more »

22 October 2014

The release from prison of one of Viet Nam’s most high profile prisoners of conscience is a positive step, but authorities must now free the scores of other peaceful... Read more »

24 October 2014

The decision to authorize the extradition to Russia of Kazakhstani banker and opposition figure Mukhtar Ablyazov by a french Court of Appeal has set in motion a procedure... Read more »

24 October 2014

The Iranian authorities must stop the execution of a woman due to be hanged tomorrow morning after being convicted for the killing of a man whom she said tried to... Read more »