Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

16 October 2013

How General Pinochet's detention changed the meaning of justice

How General Pinochet's detention changed the meaning of justice
Augusto Pinochet was placed in police custody in London in October 1998..

Augusto Pinochet was placed in police custody in London in October 1998..

© MARTIN THOMAS/AFP/Getty Images


At a Glance

The legal battle to extradite Augusto Pinochet

July 1996
Initial criminal complaints against Augusto Pinochet lodged before the Spanish National Court.

February 1997
Spanish judicial investigations are initiated.

October 1998
Spanish judge Baltasar Garzón Real files an official warrant with the UK authorities to question Augusto Pinochet -- who is then placed in police custody in London -- and issues an international warrant of arrest to prepare the request for extradition.
The UK High Court rules that Augusto Pinochet is immune from extradition because he is a former head of state. The UK prosecution authority appeals against the High Court decision.

November 1998
The Judicial Committee of the House of Lords, the highest UK court, reverses the High Court judgment, ruling that Augusto Pinochet is not immune from prosecution.

December 1998
The Lords’ ruling is set aside, following a challenge to the composition of the judicial panel on the basis of links between one of the Law Lords and Amnesty International.

March 1999
The Law Lords rule again that Augusto Pinochet does not have immunity from prosecution for acts of torture committed when he was head of state and that he can be extradited.

October 1999
Extradition hearings against Pinochet start at Bow Street Magistrates’ Court. Magistrate Ronald Bartle orders the extradition of Pinochet.

November 1999
The Chilean government asks the UK authorities to undertake medical tests on Augusto Pinochet in order to consider his release on humanitarian grounds (dementia).

March 2000
Augusto Pinochet returns to Chile after the UK Home Secretary Jack Straw decides to halt the proceedings for his extradition to Spain on health grounds.

See video
We should not forget that Pinochet died as a fugitive from justice. He was clear that international society saw him as a criminal.
Source: 
Joan Garcés, Spanish lawyer and former advisor to Salvador Allende, the former Chilean president.

Former Chilean president Augusto Pinochet was detained in London on 16 October 1998 in a move that changed the idea of international justice forever. Fifteen years on, two of the story's key players - Spanish lawyer Joan Garcés and former Amnesty International Chile researcher Virginia Shoppeé - share their memories of an event than stunned observers on both sides of the Atlantic.

On 3 October 1998, Virginia Shoppeé was sitting at her desk in Amnesty International's London headquarters, doing her daily skim through the latest news on Chile, when she came across a surprising dispatch from L'Agence France-Presse. Chile's former president, the retired general Augusto Pinochet, was about to travel to Europe - including the UK.

Amnesty International had done a lot of work denouncing the atrocities carried out by Pinochet's regime, which was responsible for the disappearance of more than 3,000 people and the torture of thousands more in a 17-year reign.

Shoppeé's intial thought was that Pinochet’s trip to Europe offered an opportunity to highlight that work.

She discussed the issue with Javier Zúñiga, the then director of Amnesty International's Americas department, and drafted the first of many documents on Pinochet that the organization would issue in the ensuing weeks.

The document reminded all European governments, including the UK, of their obligation to detain Pinochet under the rules of the Convention against Torture. But Shoppeé admits now that she never thought Pinochet’s arrest would actually be possible:

“We issued that first document about Pinochet’s visit to Europe because we thought it was the least we could do, but we didn't expect any great repercussions. I had been in Chile seven months earlier, meeting politicians, victims and their relatives as well as NGO representatives. None of them were thinking about Pinochet’s detention. Human rights violations under his government were considered a closed case.”

However, judicial procedures to arrest Pinochet had already been started by Joan Garcés in July 1996, a Spanish lawyer and former advisor to Salvador Allende, the former Chilean president who had been ousted - and who died - in Pinochet's coup d'etat.

Garcés thought it may be possible to indict Pinochet using the principles of universal jurisdiction which, in theory, allowed any state to investigate and prosecute individuals for crimes committed in other countries.

The lawyer recalls that he was encouraged by developments relating to atrocities carried about by the military regime in Argentina:

“The Spanish National Court had admitted in 1996 a lawsuit filed by victims of torture and enforced disappearances in Argentina after Parliament had ruled in 1985 that universal jurisdiction could be applied in cases of crimes against humanity, terrorism and genocide”.

Garcés filed a similar lawsuit on Chile, and his team started to gather evidence before the Spanish National Court. Dozens of victims of the Chilean military's repression travelled to Spain to give testimonies:

“We were waiting for the appropriate moment to ask for an international arrest warrant against Pinochet. It was a complex issue. We had to wait until he travelled to a country with a judiciary that was powerful and independent enough to resist the political and diplomatic pressure that his detention would cause.”

That moment arrived when Pinochet’s visit to the UK was confirmed. On 15 October, Garcés' team filed a motion for a Pinochet's arrest warrant before the Spanish National Court to extradite him to Spain to stand trial. It was sent to the UK authorities and, early the next day, Pinochet was placed under arrest. He was held in custody at The Clinic, an expensive private hospital where he had just had an operation.

It was the first time a former head of state had been arrested based on the principle of universal jurisdiction.

Garcés’ team then worked with Amnesty International to support the extradition request. The organization took a leading role in trying to ensure the then retired general would be sent to Spain to face trial, as Shoppeé explains:

"Pinochet’s detention was a milestone in the struggle for human rights. We could not let it be just a four-sentence piece in a newspaper. We had to seize the opportunity and help bring him before a court."

UK magistrates ruled in 1999 that Pinochet should be extradited to Spain, but it never happened. The then UK Home Secretary Jack Straw ordered his release on health grounds in 2000, after a controversial medical test stated Pinochet was not fit to appear before a court and he returned to Chile a free man that same year.

Garcés and Shoppeé believe that politics came into play. However, they agree that, although the outcome of Pinochet's detention was not as they had hoped, it was an essential turning point in the fight against for human rights. Garcés says:

“English magistrates took the process seriously and, finally, the prevalent position was the one we thought was in line with the international law. But at the end of the day the British government did not allow it to happen because of political pressure from the Chilean and Spanish governments and economic, diplomatic and other dark interests."

“We should not forget that Pinochet died as a fugitive from justice. He was clear that international society saw him as a criminal."

On the day of Pinochet's return to Chile, dozens of judicial requests against him began. Shoppeé says:

“Pinochet did not come back to Chile as an innocent man - as a former president unfairly accused - but as a person guilty of human rights violations whose extradition had not been allowed for health reasons."

“The victims’ claims were again a public issue. Chile had changed. It was no more the Chile I had visited in March 1998, where nobody wanted to speak out about the military government’s crimes against humanity. Chile had to face the atrocities of its past - a past the country was denying until Pinochet was put under custody in London.”

Issue

Activists 
Impunity 
International Justice 
Torture And Ill-treatment 

Country

Chile 

Region

Americas 

@amnestyonline on twitter

News

18 September 2014

Nigeria’s police and military routinely torture women, men, and children – some as young as 12 – using a wide range of methods including beatings, shootings and rape... Read more »

19 September 2014

The Guatemalan government is fuelling the fires of conflict by failing to consult local communities before awarding mining licences to companies.

Read more »
23 September 2014

The life sentence handed down by a Chinese court to prominent Uighur academic Ilham Tohti on charges of “separatism” is an affront to justice.

Read more »
22 September 2014

Turkey began to close some of its border crossings with Syria after 130,000 Kurdish refugees poured into the country in recent days fleeing the advance of the armed group... Read more »

22 September 2014

Turkey began to close some of its border crossings with Syria after 130,000 Kurdish refugees poured into the country in recent days fleeing the advance of the armed group... Read more »