Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

1 March 2013

Brutal reign by South African police claims another victim

Brutal reign by South African police claims another victim
The latest incident is not the first time South African police thave argeted non-nationals

The latest incident is not the first time South African police thave argeted non-nationals

© Alexander Joe/AFP/GettyImages


At a Glance

* Amnesty international has documented a trend by police to resort to excessive force in response to social protests and ordinary crime for nearly ten years.

* The killing by heavily armed police of 34 striking mine workers at Marikana last August is one extreme example of this trend.

* The South African government must make a public commitment to ensure that the police stop the use of excessive force and deliberate targeted killings.

This footage is shocking. This appalling incident is the latest in an increasingly disturbing pattern of brutal police conduct in South Africa.
Source: 
Noel Kututwa, southern Africa director
Date: 
Fri, 01/03/2013


Footage of South African police tying a Mozambican man to the back of a police vehicle and dragging him down the road has been making headlines across the world.

The man is reported to have died later in a police cell from head injuries.

“This footage is shocking,” said Noel Kututwa, Amnesty International’s southern Africa director.

“This appalling incident involving excessive force is the latest in an increasingly disturbing pattern of brutal police conduct in South Africa.”

Amnesty international has been documenting an increasing trend by police to resort to excessive force in response to social protests and ordinary crime for nearly ten years. Torture and other ill-treatment, primarily in context of criminal investigations, have become habitual practices.  

The killing by heavily armed police of 34 striking mine workers at Marikana last August, and the alleged ill-treatment of some injured and arrested miners in the aftermath, is one extremely concerning example of this trend.

So are the multiple targeted killings and assaults allegedly committed by members of the Cato Manor Organized Crime Unit, based in Durban.

The Unit’s alleged victims include a taxi company owner, Bongani Mkhize, killed three months after he obtained a High Court order constraining the police from killing him, and a 15 year-old school boy, Kwazi Ndlovu, who was shot dead when heavily-armed members of the Unit burst into his home.  
 
This latest incident is not the first time South African police have used violence against non-South African nationals. In October 2011, police allegedly used excessive force during mass arrests of “suspected illegal foreign nationals” in Nyanga township, Cape Town. The people affected included recognized refugees who had shown their documents to the police.

There have been, however, some encouraging signs of commitment to ending impunity for police brutality.

The Judicial Commission of Inquiry into the Marikana killings is beginning to probe more deeply into the evidence of the police actions at Marikana. Twenty-eight members of the Cato Manor unit are currently standing trial for 116 offences, including 28 counts of murder.

In 2012, Parliament held public hearings in 2012 on a new bill to combat torture. Also in 2012, the powers of the police oversight body, the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID), were strengthened under a new law, making the police liable to criminal charges for failure to cooperate with their investigations. 

The IPID receives annually more than 700 new cases for investigation of suspicious deaths in custody or in other policing contexts.
 
“The Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) must be fully supported in conducting its investigation to ensure those responsible for this latest incident are brought to justice,” said Kututwa.

“Amnesty International urges the South African government to make a public commitment to ensure that the police stop the use of excessive force and deliberate targeted killings.”

Issue

Extrajudicial Executions And Other Unlawful Killings 

Country

South Africa 

Region

Africa 

@amnestyonline on twitter

News

19 August 2014

The World Bank endorsed the Lagos state government’s inadequate compensation package for thousands of people forcibly evicted from an informal settlement.

Read more »
15 August 2014

The number of killings perpetrated by the police is on the rise again in the Dominican Republic whilst legislation intended to fix the problem stalls and stagnates in Congress... Read more »

19 August 2014

Court ruling directing the release of prisoner of conscience Irom Sharmila because there were no grounds for charging her with attempted suicide is a legal and moral victory... Read more »

06 August 2014

Ukrainian MP and former presidential candidate Oleg Lyashko has been “detaining” – in effect abducting – and ill-treating individuals across eastern Ukraine with total impunity... Read more »

20 August 2014

The apparent execution-style killing by the Islamic State (IS) armed group of a US reporter who went missing in Syria constitutes a war crime.

Read more »