Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

16 April 2013

Teng Biao: “In China, courts are told what decision to make in important cases, including on the death penalty.”

Teng Biao: “In China, courts are told what decision to make in important cases, including on the death penalty.”
Ai Weiwei, internationally renowned artist, and Teng Biao, a human rights lawyer, wearing 'Free Chen Guangcheng' t-shirts, China.

Ai Weiwei, internationally renowned artist, and Teng Biao, a human rights lawyer, wearing 'Free Chen Guangcheng' t-shirts, China.

© Private


At a Glance

  • 682 executions were confirmed in 21 countries in 2012.
  • Five biggest executors were China, Iran, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, and the USA.
  • Abolitionist countries rose to 97 in 2012.
See video

Click to enlarge

© Amnesty International


Death penalty trends (Click to enlarge)

© Amnesty International


The most urgent matter is to reduce the number of miscarriages of justice. We don’t have judicial independence. Judges are influenced or even controlled by the local police or the Communist Party.
Source: 
Teng Biao, Chinese lawyer and activist

Speaking out against the death penalty in China can be a risky business as it can be perceived as a challenge to the state's authority.

The Asian giant executed more people than the rest of the world put together in 2012 -- although the true number of executions may never be known as it remains a state secret.

Few people have been more vocal in their opposition to this ultimate cruel punishment than Teng Biao, a 39-year-old Beijing lawyer and academic.

He has dedicated the past 10 years of his life to fight for human rights in China. His calls for political and legal reforms have led to him being detained, tortured and stripped of his licence to practice law.

But despite it all, he remains determined to carry on.

A few years ago, he co-founded China Against the Death Penalty, a network of lawyers working on death penalty cases, particularly those involving torture, mental illness or wrongful convictions.

He once wrote that the “Chinese people are too bloodthirsty to give up the death penalty as the state’s favourite method of sweet revenge."

“There is a long way to go to end the death penalty. I don’t know how long but we must continue our efforts,” he said in an interview in Hong Kong where he is a visiting scholar at the Chinese University of Hong Kong.

Unfair trials
Amnesty International’s latest global death penalty report highlights how death sentences in China continue to be imposed after unfair trials. For Teng Biao this is the most pressing issue.

“The most urgent matter is to reduce the number of miscarriages of justice. We don’t have judicial independence. Judges are influenced or even controlled by the local police or the Communist Party.

“In many cases the police tortured a suspect and the judges use this evidence even when they know it has been obtained illegally. A judge is supposed to exclude evidence obtained through torture but because the court is not independent they instead listen to the police and Communist Party officials.”

Limited progress
While progress has been slow, there have been some limited reforms in the past two years. These include reducing the number of crimes that carry the death penalty and giving powers to the Supreme People’s Court, China’s highest court, to overturn death sentences in any case. But Teng Biao remains sceptical as to the difference these reforms will make.

“There’s progress in the new laws but the reality is the law on paper is different to the law in action. It’s very rare for a decision by a lower court to be overturned on appeal. If a case is overturned it will reflect badly on the local judges so many higher courts are unwilling to do that.

“While the changes may mean the number of executions may go down, any meaningful judicial reform remains difficult.”

As well as advocating for changes to China’s legal system, China Against the Death Penalty defends individuals who face a death sentence.

“We have a group of lawyers that a family may contact and ask for our help. Other times we may read reports and contact the family.  We can be involved when an individual is arrested and we will defend them at the first trial all the way through. Other times we may do our work on the side and review the procedure.”

Unfair punishment
The group recently urged the Chinese authorities not to execute Li Yan, a woman sentenced to death for killing her husband, despite evidence that she had suffered sustained domestic violence.

Amnesty International’s experts also expressed concern that the judges did not fully take into account the evidence of sustained abuse that Li Yan suffered.

Li Yan’s case sparked public outrage both within China and outside. Tens of thousands of people called for her not to be executed.

“Li Yan’s case is very urgent as she could be executed at any moment. We will do anything we can to help her.

“Her case is a very good example as to why it is necessary to abolish the death penalty in China. But most of our cases are not like this, most defendants are innocent.”

Teng Biao is frank when asked if the death penalty in China will be abolished in his lifetime.

“I think the end of the death penalty is more difficult than seeing a democratic system. Without democracy there is no way for China to abolish the death penalty. But many human rights activists are optimistic towards democracy.”

Such optimism must help when up against the world’s biggest executioner. And Teng Biao’s courage and dedication shine through when he talks about his work.

“I cannot give up. I have a responsibility. What I am doing is right. I can contribute to a better politics and a better China.”

Campaigns

Abolish the death penalty  

Country

China 

Region

Asia And The Pacific 

Issue

Death Penalty 

Index card

Death sentences and executions in 2012

Download:


This document is also available in:

Spanish
French
Arabic
Chinese

@amnestyonline on twitter

News

24 October 2014

Equatorial Guinea’s government should reveal the names and the reasons for the arrest of all prisoners set to benefit from the country’s newly announced amnesty on... Read more »

24 October 2014

The dismissive reaction of the Dominican Republic to the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ ruling on human rights abuses suffered by Dominicans of Haitian descent and... Read more »

22 October 2014

The release from prison of one of Viet Nam’s most high profile prisoners of conscience is a positive step, but authorities must now free the scores of other peaceful... Read more »

24 October 2014

The decision to authorize the extradition to Russia of Kazakhstani banker and opposition figure Mukhtar Ablyazov by a french Court of Appeal has set in motion a procedure... Read more »

24 October 2014

The Iranian authorities must stop the execution of a woman due to be hanged tomorrow morning after being convicted for the killing of a man whom she said tried to... Read more »